2023 Match of the Year List
2023 was an odd year, with a lot of great stuff scattered around, but I didn’t feel like there were any obvious picks for me. If I re-wrote this list in 2 months, it would be in a completely different order.
Honourable Mentions
- Roman Reigns vs Sami Zayn, WWE, February 18
- Gunther vs Drew McIntyre vs Sheamus, WWE, April 1
- Mina Shirakawa vs Saya Kamitani, Stardom, April 23
- Suzu Suzuki vs Syuri, Stardom, July 23
- Jaguar Yokota, Momoe Nakanishi, & Nanae Takahashi vs Momo Watanabe, Starlight Kid, & Yuu, Stardom, August 19
Now, onto the list!
#10
Swerve Strickland (c) vs Nick Wayne
“DEFY World Championship”
DEFY The Realest
Washington Hall
April 8
Swerve had one of the best heel performances in years, and this is your perfect veteran heel champion putting over a youngster match!
Swerve’s control and build-up of heat was perfection, and Wayne’s hope spots were well placed. Some of the high spots were amazing, especially Wayne diving from the stage into the ring but Swerve timing it to do a dive and meeting him in the air. There was one kick out that I felt took the match out a little, but all the callbacks to previous matches and earlier in the match and the finish were brilliant. It’s a great old school, but with modern moves, match up!
#9
The Usos (c) vs Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn
“WWE Unified Tag Team Championship”
WWE WrestleMania 39: Saturday
April 1, 2023
SoFi Stadium
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
Although this match should have been the perfect end to Roman Reigns’ title reign, at least it was the perfect end to the reign of the Usos.
It was one of the best face-in-peril segments ever in WWE history. It led to a great hot tag for Owens. The staredown was great, and the ending was immensely satisfying with a Sami Zayn victory. A rare, perfect ending for the WWE.
#8
Titan (c) vs Mascara Dorada 2.0
“CMLL World Middleweight Championship”
CMLL Noche de Campeones
Arena Mexico
September 29
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
I haven’t seen much of the new Mascara Dorada, but he is insanely good for a wrestler who debuted in 2021. He reminds me of Rey Mysterio Jr., who came around and blew everyone away with his flying, but it never looked like he was showing off, but always competing in a match. Dorada is the same way.
Titan is no slouch, as he’s been great for a long time. With all the great flying, the spot that really hit me was Titan doing a double stomp from the top rope to Dorada on the apron. As it built towards the finish, all the submission nearfalls were amazing. It was a great match and probably in my top ten matches of the year.
#7
Becky Lynch vs Trish Stratus
“Cage Match”
WWE Payback
PPG Paints Arena
September 2
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
This was a perfect WWE cage match. It was not built around trying to do cool moves; it was built around the feud and legacy. For once, no blood, after being rammed into the cage, was perfectly covered, as Trish had a giant welt on her forehead. The tributes to the first-ever WWE women’s cage match and other cage matches in WWE history were perfectly done. They were even somewhat subtle, like the Bret-Owen superplex and the outside interference door slamming into the face. I loved the finishing sequence so much, where Becky had enough of Trish’s lackey, so she locked her in the cage too and took her out, leading to catching Trish on the top of the cage and hitting a super Manhandle slam.
#6
Arisa Nakajima (c) vs Saree
“SEAdLINNNG Beyond The Sea Championship”
SEAdLINNNG 8th Anniversary
Korakuen Hall
August 25
This felt like a classic stiff Nakajima battle from her prime, and it’s so nice to see her at that level still and Sareee getting back to being at that level. The strikes were, of course, on point, and some of the flying double stomps by Nakajima were just vicious. Actually, everything was vicious, and it had a great pace throughout!
#5
Roman Reigns & Solo Sikoa vs The Usos
“Bloodline Civil War”
WWE Money in The Bank
The O2
July 1
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
It was one of the best tag team matches in WWE history and great WWE wrestling. It worked so well playing off storylines and building drama setting up the finish of what the fans wanted, which sets up a huge match down the line.
It started pretty traditionally with a great shine by The Usos, followed by a face in peril by Jey, including an amazing hot tag tease where Jimmy was pulled off the apron by Solo at the last second. After a fun hot tag, the match started building towards the finish with no silly kick-outs, as partner’s made the saves. There was a great near fall where Roman stacked both The Usos, only for them to kick out. I loved Roman not sure what to do, and in shock, Solo just starts kicking ass and is like Roman, what the fuck? After some more great action, we got the big shocking finish. Awesome.
#4
Queen’s Quest (AZM, Hina, Lady C, Miyu Amasaki, Saya Kamitani & Utami Hayashishita) vs Oedo Tai (Momo Watanabe, Natsuko Tora, Rina, Ruaka, Saki Kashima & Starlight Kid)
“Loser Must Leave Unit Steel Cage Match”
Stardom Sunshine
Yoyogi National Gymnasium #2
June 25
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
The same rules as the other cage match, but the last person in the ring has to leave their unit this time. This works so much better because escaping saves your ass, even if it puts your team behind. Also, each escape felt like a huge accomplishment, as they were all battles. After people escaped, they still battled the other unit on the floor!
It was tremendous storytelling with great hatred and drama between the teams. Utami establishing herself as Queen’s Quest’s ass was the stand-out story as she helps Kamitani escape putting herself alone two on one. That led to a great finishing sequence with Utami bleeding, the teasing of a split between Utami and Kamitani, and Tora destroying Utami to leave, only to have Kashima be the final loser.
#3
Gunther (c) vs Chad Gable
“WWE Intercontinental Championship”
WWE Monday Night Raw
Spectrum Center
September 4
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month blog post:
This played off the previous match and built upon it. Gable knew he could win, and Gunther had doubts for almost the first time in his reign. Gable again fought from underneath, but here, his hope spots meant more. The comeback and the Gable’s attempts to win were electric. This had the best ankle lock submission nearfalls I have ever seen. When Gunther finally survived and got back on offense, there was no back-and-forth bullshit. He delivered a bunch of vicious offense and just pinned him clean. The camera immediately moved to Gable’s daughter crying in the first row. This might be my match of the year.
#2
Adam Page vs Swerve Strickland
“Texas Death Match”
AEW Full Gear
The Kia Forum
November 18
It’s awesome to see such a violent modern grudge match that doesn’t have the pitfalls that I would expect in a match like this. Swerve is a perfect heel, and maintaining that throughout this match only adds to the story. Of course, people can point to the blood-drinking, cinder blocks, staples, barbed-wire, and piledrivers onto the guardrail for huge moments, but what stood out was the masterful job Swerve did keeping the heat on Page.
#1
Giulia (c) vs Tam Nakano
“World of Stardom Championship”
Stardom All-Star Grand Queendom
Yokohama Arena
April 23
From The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Week post:
This may be my favourite feud of all time now. It’s gone on for years and has had many classics and this one may have been my favourite of the bunch. It did feel the most violent as their hatred had grown and grown over time. I loved that they saw red and didn’t even try to wrestle at the start before they realized they had a title to win. The snapmare from the top to the table looked so vicious, I was dying! By the end, they both tried everything before the Steiner Screwdriver by Tam finished Giulia off.
Years of Stardom booking long reigns really made Tam’s victory feel special.
Coming Soon
The top 25 wrestlers of 2023 list should be ready shortly, plus at the end of every month, I’ll write up the top 25 matches I watched during it.
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group, and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
How Can You Help?
Callen-Lorde is the global leader in LGBTQ healthcare. Since the days of Stonewall, we have been transforming lives in LGBTQ communities through excellent comprehensive care, provided free of judgment and regardless of ability to pay. In addition, we are continuously pioneering research, advocacy, and education to drive positive change around the world because we believe healthcare is a human right.
Please donate to Callen Lorde!
The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month (October 2023)
I was really all over the place in October, but one thing kept me excited, and that was going through WCW’s 1996. We are in 1996 for our Joshi weekly watches, and I thought I’d get a head start on the rest of the world. Other GWE years I want to tackle are just not clicking with me right now.
Also, 2023 is turning out to be pretty damn cool, eh?
#25
John Morrison (c) vs CM Punk
“ECW Heavyweight Championship”
ECW on SciFi
September 1, 2007, aired September 4, 2007
These two had a long series, so they knew each other well and did a lot of counters. The crowd is really hot, and it’s a very exciting match with a great finishing stretch.
Rating: 7.25/10
#24
La Catalina vs Stephanie Vaquer
“CMLL World Women’s Championship”
CMLL Noche de Campeones
September 29, 2023
Vaquer’s offense outside the ring was so vicious. They both worked stiff and had a very intense match that was a great counterpoint to a lot of the more high-flying of the rest of the card.
Rating: 7.25/10
#23
Bruno Sammartino (c) vs Stan Hansen
“WWWF Heavyweight Championship Steel Cage Match”
WWWF on August 7, 1976
A famous match with Bruno getting revenge after Hasnen broke his neck. The crowd is so into Bruno’s revenge, and he gets it here with lots of blood and violence.
Rating: 7.25/10
#22
Becky Lynch (c) vs Lyra Valkyria
“NXT Women’s Championship”
NXT Halloween Havoc
October 24, 2023
A tremendous main event, with Valkyria playing the big underdog against the legendary Lynch. It was filled with hope spots and nearfalls for Valyria, and Lynch did a great job of controlling the action and trying to find ways to put away the underdog. Some of my favourite types of wrestling matches, and this was a good version of that.
Rating: 7.75/10
#21
Mistico (c) vs Virus
“World Historic Middleweight Championship”
CMLL Noche de Campeones
September 29, 2023
Mistico is so spectacular, and Virus is so well grounded they make a perfect counterpoint for each other and a beautiful match to watch.
Rating: 7.75/10
#20
Rey Mysterio Jr. (c) vs Super Calo
WCW Fall Brawl: War Games
September 15, 1996
Calo works over Rey’s arm so well and also hits some great dives and throws for the first large portion of this match. Rey sells his arm all the way through his comeback. A great stretch of nerfalls and Rey hits a double springboard hurrcanrana for the win utilizing the double ring. It was one of the better Cruiserweight matches in WCW history.
Rating: 7.75/10
#19
Blackjack Lanza & Bobby Duncum (c) vs The High Flyers
“AWA World Tag Team Championships”
AWA on July 7, 1977
It’s a really hot crowd in a very classic tag team format match. Lazna and Duncum bumped huge when The High Flyers were on offense, and The Flyers sold great on defense. It got more exciting as it went along to a great finish.
Rating: 7.75/10
#18
Dean Malenko (c) vs Rey Mysterio Jr.
“WCW World Cruiserweight Championship”
WCW The Great American Bash
June 16, 1996
I’ve felt this match was odd because it’s Rey’s WCW debut, and Malenko grounds him for 3/4 of it by working his arm. The comeback is tremendous, though, and the arm work is really good. Truly the start of the new WCW cruiserweight era.
Rating: 7.75/10
#17
Natsupoi vs Tam Nakano
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
September 30, 2023
Former enemies and current teammates can be really cool in a match against each other, and this one was that. It started with the know each other so well spots, but then they started to dig back into their former hatred. There were great nearfalls before a finish that was a little bit of a surprise, with Natsupoi pinning the Champion.
Rating: 8/10
#16
Suzu Suzuki vs Tam Nakano
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
September 9, 2023
It was an excellent GP match, with Suzuki going for death and Nakano’s amazing selling leading the way. The last third was a tremendous run to the finish.
Rating: 8/10
#15
Umaga (c) vs Jeff Hardy
“WWE Intercontinental Championship”
WWE The Great American Bash
July 22, 2007
It was an amazing David vs Goliath match, with Hardy having awesome hope spots while Umaga killed him throughout. When it got to Jeff’s comeback, it was electric, and when Umaga did the run for the finish, it was death. Perfect wrestling.
Rating: 8/10
#14
Hazuki vs Suzu Suzuki
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
September 23, 2023
It’s all killer, no filler heated GP match.
Rating: 8/10
#13
Rey Mysterio Jr. (c) vs Dean Malenko
“WCW World Cruiserweight Championship”
WCW Halloween Havoc
October 27, 1996
After an amazing shine segment by Rey where he got his stolen mask back, Dean grounds him. The leg attacks are great, as well as Rey’s selling. In 1996, few had better comebacks than Rey. The finishing stretch is so great, ending with a vicious super bomb by Dean!
Rating: 8/10
#12
Mei Seira vs Nanae Takahashi
“Passion Injection”
Stardom New Blood 11
September 29, 2023
One of the highlights of 2023 is Nanae vs younger wrestlers, injecting them with passion. Mei was amazing, fighting to take it to Nanae and pushing her to the limits. Nanae was also great pushing back against it.
Rating: 8/10
#11
Maika vs MIRAI
“5STAR Grand Prix: Blue Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
September 30, 2023
The winner wins the Blue Stars block, so there is extra drama here in this awesome hoss battle.
Rating: 8/10
#10
Aja Kong vs Yumiko Hotta
“Japan Grand Prix”
AJW Japan Grand Prix
July 14, 1996
Kong completely brutalizes Hotta’s leg in the most violent way possible, and Hotta sells it so well. Hotta worked from underneath and had some good hope spots. For some reason, Hotta always really steps up against Kong!
Rating: 8.5/10
#9
Mistico vs Templario
“Best 2/3 Falls”
CMLL Super Viernes
October 13, 2023
Mistico might be the best babyface in the world right now. Being so over really helps, but the great selling and hope spots, added with the spectacular moves, make him so loveable. I love that Mistico dominated for a large early portion of this match until Templario got a lucky comeback in the second fall, leading to him destroying Mistsco. The finishing sequence and the comeback by Mistico ruled! I don’t want to discount Templario here; he’s a great rudo, too.
Rating: 8.5/10
#8
Antonio Inoki (c) vs Andre the Giant
“Real World Martial Arts Championship”
NJPW Toukon Series
October 7, 1976
It was a tremendous David vs Goliath contest that was really focused on the strategy of both. Inoki was amazing at finding his spots where Andre would leave an opening.
Rating: 8.5/10
#7
Maika vs Suzu Suzuki
“5STAR Grand Prix: Final”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
September 30, 2023
A surprising final, which had to be changed due to the injuries. However, it added an extra level of excitement because the winner could have been anyone. It was an intense, stiff, and exciting match, with both stepping up their game to win the 5STAR! It was really a perfect tournament final match, as either could have won throughout, and they played it as two equally matched competitors.
I’m very excited to see how far Suzuki can go at such a young age!
Rating: 8.5/10
#6
Ultimate Dragon (c) vs Rey Misterio Jr.
“J-Crown Championship”
WCW World War 3
November 24, 1996
Most of the match is a squash, with Dragon unleashing amazing offense, including one of the best and most brutal running power bombs ever. Rey is amazing at selling, and when he gets a comeback near the end, it’s electric with spectacular moves. The finish is otherworldly, with Rey attempting to complete the comeback with a springboard rana, only for Dragon to catch him and slingshot Rey off the top rope into a vicious sit-down power bomb for the win. It is a classic and very cool, for it does not follow the usual formula.
Rating: 8.75/10
#5
Becky Lynch (c) vs Tiffany Stratton
“NXT Women’s Championship Extreme Rules Match”
NXT No Mercy
September 30, 2023
Stratton is very impressive, with amazing physical skills and tremendous presence. She wasn’t just carried along by Lynch but added a lot. This was one of the better all-over-the-arena weapons matches I can recall from the WWE in a long time. The spots were violent and vicious, and the nearfalls were unbelievable. Great finish, too.
Rating: 8.75/10
#4
Manami Toyota vs Meiko Satomura
“Battlefield WAR Tournament Second Round”
Sendai Girls Live Vol. 8
May 6, 2007
It was really cool to see generational legends go at it, and they delivered. The early portions of Toyota using her veteran status to keep control of Meiko was really great. As they build up to the match, they had a great bomb-throwing segment and finishing rush.
Rating: 8.75/10
#3
Antonio Inoki vs Big Van Vader
NJPW Wrestling World In Tokyo Dome
January 4, 1996
Two legendary though guys stand up and fight each other on the biggest stage with a red-hot crowd. This is amazing. Both really go for the kill throughout, and the Vader German Suplex spot is incredibly memorable.
Rating: 9/10
#2
Titan (c) vs Mascara Dorada
“CMLL World Middleweight Championship”
CMLL Noche de Campeones
September 29, 2023
I haven’t seen too much of the new Mascara Dorada, but for a wrestler who debuted in 2021, he is insanely good. He reminds me of Rey Mysterio Jr., who came around and blew everyone away with his flying, but it never looked like he was showing off, but always competing in a match. Dorada is the same way.
Titan is no slouch, as he’s been great for a long time. With all the great flying, the spot that really hit me was Titan doing a double stomp from the top rope to Dorada on the apron. As it built towards the finish, all the submission nearfalls were amazing. It was a great match and probably in my top ten matches of the year.
Rating: 9/10
#1
Combat Toyoda (c) vs Megumi Kudo
“FMW Independent Women’s & WWA Women’s Title No Ropes Barbed Wire Current Blast Death Match”
FMW Fighting Creation: 7th Anniversary Show
May 5, 1996
Not much to say. It’s the best deathmatch and the best FMW match in history. It’s dramatic, it’s emotional, and it’s great.
Rating: 9.66/10
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group, and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
How Can You Help?
Callen-Lorde is the global leader in LGBTQ healthcare. Since the days of Stonewall, we have been transforming lives in LGBTQ communities through excellent comprehensive care, provided free of judgment and regardless of ability to pay. In addition, we are continuously pioneering research, advocacy, and education to drive positive change around the world because we believe healthcare is a human right.
Please donate to Callen Lorde!
The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Month (September 2023)
I took a little break from GWE watching; I only had two 76/77 matches on the list this month. I was off-wrestling this month, but I got in a lot of the Stardom 5STAR and started to get back into CMLL.
#25
Superstar Billy Graham (c) vs Dusty Rhodes
“WWWF Heavyweight Championship Texas Death Match”
WWWF
October 24, 1977
This was bloody, with a superheated crowd in an intense brawl. It doesn’t really hit high gear, though, and the finish stunk, but a damn good match worth watching.
Rating: 7/10
#24
Hazuki, Shinobu Kandori, & Takako Inoue vs Natsupoi, Saori Anou, & Tam Nakano
Stardom MidSummer Fes
August 19, 2023
It’s a fun match, putting legends with current starts. All the legends hit their stuff and looked awesome, but the current stars carried the bulk of the work. It’s a textbook and is well worth watching stuff here.
Rating: 7/10
#23
Chigusa Nagayo vs Megumi Kudo
FMW New Year Generation
January 10, 1996
An amazing-paced 7-minute match where they fought with a great struggle like warriors! The power bomb finish was brutal!
Rating: 7/10
#22
Kaoru Ito & Manami Toyota vs Double Inoue
AJW Zenjo Strongest
January 3, 1996
This was just a super fun tag with a really hot finishing sequence and an insanely fast giant swing by Kyoko.
Rating: 7.25/10
#21
Akira Hokuto & Mima Shimoda (c) vs Double Inoue
“WWWA Tag Team Championship Best 2/3 Falls”
AJW Ota Ward Champion Legend
January 22, 1996
LCO work as psychotic heels against the sympathetic Double Inoue team, and it helps this tag for the first couple of falls. The third fall is tremendous action.
Rating: 7.25/10
#20
MIRAI (c) vs Konami
“Wonder of Stardom Championship”
Stardom 5STAR Special In Hiroshima
September 3, 2023
I really dug this title defense. Konami’s arm offense and kicks were on point, and MIRAI’s selling was tremendous. I loved her comeback and the finishing sequence, too. MIRAI’s lariats are so brutal.
Rating: 7.25/10
#19
La Jarochita & Lluvia vs Stephanie Vaquer & Zeuxis
“CMLL World Women’s Tag Team Title Match”
CMLL 90 Aniversario
September 16, 2023
A great opener to the Aniversario and a really fun tag match with some amazing dives and great double-team moves. There was a viciousness to this that made it extra appealing.
Rating: 7.25
#18
Momo Watanabe vs Saori Anou
“5STAR Grand Prix: Blue Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
August 15, 2023
It was a real blast where Momo was trying to knock out Anou all match, from an opening sneak attack to using her baseball bat and vicious heavy offense. Anou is pretty good from fighting underneath, so it’s worth watching.
Rating: 7.25/10
#17
Mariah May vs Mina Shirakawa
“5STAR Grand Prix: Blue Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
August 15, 2023
These two have been the most improved wrestlers on earth in the last two years, and they went out and had a good match between teammates. Mina’s leg work was on point as ever, and Mariah has developed some killer offense.
Rating: 7.25/10
#16
Mayu Iwatani vs Syuri
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Special In Hiroshima
September 3, 2023
These two are just great, and even in an undercard match, they will deliver something awesome. It was intense and stiff and led to a great finish.
Rating: 7.5/10
#15
Aja Kong vs Combat Toyoda
FMW New Year Generation
January 10, 1996
A wild brawl all over the arena with Combat bleeding and weapons. It’s a real fun hoss battle well worth your time.
Rating: 7.5/10
#14
Hazuki vs Syrui
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
August 15, 2023
A full-throttle intense 10-minute sprint that I loved. Two of my favourites doing everything to win their tournament match, but not in an epic way, but in a that put the other away as soon as possible way.
Rating: 7.5/10
#13
Manami Toyota (c) vs Kyoko Inoue
“WWWA World Championship”
AJW Wrestling Queendom
March 31, 1996
Putting aside the horrible design to not have Kyoko win and to have her lose to her own finish, this match was pretty damn good. The crowd really wanted Kyoko to win, which made every nerafall hot. The nerafalls all felt big, and it got better and better as it went.
Rating: 8/10
#12
Bomber Hikari, Chigusa Nagayo, & Sonoko Kato vs Eagle Sawai, Jenn Yukari, & Michiko Nagashima
LLPW
March 12, 1996
This is a rematch from a GAEA match higher on the list, and although it’s still pretty wild and a great match, it doesn’t hit the high levels the other match hit. The clipping makes it harder to rank, too.
Rating: 8/10
#11
Mayu Iwatani vs Tam Nakano
“5STAR Grand Prix: Red Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
August 15, 2023
Two legends of Stardom go at it for 15 minutes straight, trying to knock the other out. It’s as good as a 15-minute tournament match draw could be, really. These two need a big title match one day.
Rating: 8/10
#10
KAIRI & Saori Anou vs Unagi Sayaka & Sareee
AJPW Giant Series
September 8, 2023
Outside of the novelty of seeing these four, some of my favourites, in an AJPW ring, the match delivered. It was a great tag match where everyone was stepping up their game. Each team had really good team chemistry and double-team moves, too. The last few minutes were absolutely tremendous stuff.
Rating: 8/10
#9
CM Punk (c) vs Samoa Joe
“Real World Championship”
AEW All In London
August 27, 2023
This was a great opener and the only match I wanted to watch from this show. There were some nice nods to their previous matches with the headlock before Joe killed Punk into the table and blooded him up. Punk worked amazingly from underneath, and his comeback was fun, especially the Wrestlemania III tribute. A fun finishing stretch ended it. Punk then posed with a trans flag to push the match up even higher!
Rating: 8/10
#8
AZM vs Utami Hayashishita
“5STAR Grand Prix: Blue Stars”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix
August 15, 2023
The main event in Korakuen Hall delivered in a big way as teammates fought in the 5STAR. AZM used her high speed skills to try to sneak in a victory, while Utami used her power to pick her apart. It was a perfect power vs speed match.
Rating: 8.25/10
#7
Lince Dorado & Samuray del Sol vs. Soberano Jr. & Titan
“Best 2/3 Falls”
CMLL 90 Aniversario
September 16, 2023
The Lucha House Party makes a surprisingly good gringo rudo tag team here, and this was a dynamic, exciting tag. The first two falls were perfect, with great spots and good build-up. The third fall got a little extra, but this was filled with spectacular spots and some good playing character work.
Rating: 8.25/10
#6
Dragon Rojo Jr. vs Templario
“Mask vs Mask”
CMLL 90 Aniversario
September 16, 2023
There’s nothing like a mask vs mask match to end a CMLL Anniversary show, and this was a good one. I loved Dragon Rojo Jr. on offense for the first half; he kind of reminded me of Kikuchiyo in his movement. Templario’s comeback had a lot of spectacular dives, but the finishing stretch seemed like a letdown from what they were building.
Rating: 8.5/10
#5
Angel de Oro vs Volador, Jr.
“Hair vs Hair”
CMLL 90 Aniversario
September 16, 2023
A dramatic and great hair vs hair match made even better with Volador’s shoulder injury, making all his moves look more spectacular. I love these high-stakes matches. It makes everything feel way more important. This wasn’t just a spot fest. There was some great hate and submissions mixed in there.
Rating: 8.75/10
#4
Bomber Hikari, Chigusa Nagayo, & Sonoko Kato vs Eagle Sawai, Jenn Yukari, & Michiko Nagashima
GAEA War Is A Friday Night
February 16, 1996
This is as fun as a wild all over the arena crazy brawl can be. Chigusa and Eagle just killing each other in the audience is a blast, but the story of Kato losing her shit was amazing. Blood and brawling, GAEA is such a great promotion.
Rating: 8.75/10
#3
Jaguar Yokota, Momoe Nakanishi, & Nanae Takahashi vs Momo Watanabe, Starlight Kid, & Yuu
Stardom MidSummer Fes
August 19, 2023
This was an exciting trios match main event. There was so much great action with everyone, especially the legends, getting their chance to shine. The action was really classic Joshi. I’m so blown away by how great Nakanishi was after 18 years of not wrestling a real match. She looked like she could main event today on a consistent basis. Unbelievable.
Rating: 9/10
#2
Terry Funk (c) vs Jumbo Tsuruta
“NWA World Heavyweight Championship Best 2/3 Falls”
AJPW NWA Champion Series”
June 11, 1976
One thing I immediately loved about this match was each fall was built like a regular match, albeit the later ones got shorter and went quicker toward finishing sequences. It has that great feel-out segment that leads to them figuring out what to do. Funk doing Jumbo’s finisher to him was fascinating, as I had no idea people were doing that before the 2000s. It is just tremendously well-built, and once it going going, it is an exciting match.
Rating: 9/10
#1
“Match of the Month”
Becky Lynch vs Trish Stratus
“Cage Match”
WWE Payback
September 2, 2023
This was a perfect WWE cage match. It was not built around trying to do cool moves; it was built around the feud and legacy. For once, no blood, after being rammed into the cage, was perfectly covered, as Trish had a giant welt on her forehead. The tributes to the first-ever WWE women’s cage match and other cage matches in WWE history were perfectly done. They were even somewhat subtle, like the Bret-Owen superplex and the outside interference door slamming into the face. I loved the finishing sequence so much, where Becky had enough of Trish’s lackey, so she locked her in the cage too and took her out, leading to catching Trish on the top of the cage and hitting a super Manhandle slam. It was a brilliant match and will be near the top matches of 2023 for me!
Rating: 9/10
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group, and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
How Can You Help?
Callen-Lorde is the global leader in LGBTQ healthcare. Since the days of Stonewall, we have been transforming lives in LGBTQ communities through excellent comprehensive care, provided free of judgment and regardless of ability to pay. In addition, we are continuously pioneering research, advocacy, and education to drive positive change around the world because we believe healthcare is a human right.
Please donate to Callen Lorde!
The Greatest Wrestlers of 2019
In route to putting together my top 100 list of the Greatest Wrestlers Ever, I am going through each year and putting together a list for that particular year. Previously, on the podcast “Maybe Not Taue”, I put together a list for 1985, 1990, 1997, & 2021. You can listen to those here. 1983, 1993, 1994, 2001, 2004, 2010, 2015, & 2022 are on the blog.
2019
I love 2019; it was the year I was so into watching almost every women’s indie match, and the first year, I started to dip into Stardom.
The List
All of the below stats are from Cagematch. Yes, they are not perfect.
The recommended matches are not a definitive list. It’s a list of matches I have watched for this process, plus matches on my spreadsheet from before. I will not go beyound 5 matches.
The matches listed are all 7/10 or higher; if they are bolded, they are 8/10 or higher.
Honourable Mentions
- Arisa Nakajima
- ASUKA
- Charlotte Flair
- Jonathan Gresham
- Kairi Sane
- Roman Reigns
- Thunder Rosa
#25
Kris Statlander
Years Unranked: 2021 & 2022
Matches: 134
Places Worked: Beyond, CAP, NYWC, AAW, QOC, Limitless, WrestlePro, FSCW, AEW, CW, CZW, SHIMMER, WSU, ZERO1 USA, B!P, GCW, WWR, Femmes Fatles, AML, C4, IWTV, MTW, BCW, Dropkick Depression, Bar Wrestling, CHIKARA, EVOLVE, SHINE, REVOLVER, Sabotage, HMW, HOG, ROH, PWM, NOVA Pro, BLP, & WWE
Titles Held: NYWC Starlet Championship, IWTV Independent Wrestling Championship, B!P Bedlam Championship, WSUA Spirit Championship, CAP Television Championship, & AAW Women’s Championship
Tournaments: Queen of the North (finals), Beyond Treasure Hunter Tournament (winner), CZW Best of the Best 18, NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling King & Queen Tournament w/ Orange Cassidy (finals), Making Town Classic Tournament, REVOLVER One Night Tournament, & CHIKARA King of Trios w/ Nick Gage & Thomas Santell
Weirdly, Kris Statlander wasn’t even on my GWE spreadsheet. However, after I put out my match of the year list, Statlander was on their twice! I am saying her year was sneaky good as she completely broke out on the Indies and worked everywhere, bringing a different character and some fresh excitement to the scene.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Ashley Vox, “Unsanctioned,” Limitless, January 11 (#5 MOTY)
- vs Orange Cassidy, IWTV, May 26
- vs Joey Janella, Beyond, June 12 (#8 MOTY)
- vs Kimber Lee, “Cage,” Beyond, July 28
- vs Mercedes Martinez, Beyond, November 14
- plus more
#24
Tsukasa Fujimoto
Previous Ranking: 2021 (13th)
Years Unranked: 2010, 2015, & 2022
Matches: 125
Places Worked:
Title Held:
Tournament:
The veteran Fujimoto is always a threat for this list, as long as there are enough opportunities and footage of her. If she branched out from Ice Ribbon more to give herself more variety, she would probably be higher on this list. She is a dynamo in the ring with very sound psychology and a knack for having exciting finishing sequences.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Maya Yukihi, Ice Ribbon, August 3
- vs Sareee, Ice Ribbon, September 14
- w/ Tsukushi vs Maya Yukihi & Risa Sera, Ice Ribbon, November 3
#23
Nanae Takahashi
Previous Ranking: 2004 (11th) & 2010 (20th)
Years Unranked: 1997, 2001, 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 54
Places Worked: SEAdLINNNG, Marvelous, Gatoh Move, WAVE, ZERO1, Ice Ribbon, AWG, Dragon Gate, & NagoJo
Titles Held: SEAdLINNNG Beyond The Sea Championship & Blast Queen Championship
Always the hard-hitting veteran, it is nice to see Nanae sneak onto the list this late into her career. It does help running a promotion where you can give yourself a lot of cool opportunities.
Recommended Matches:
- vs ASUKA, SEAdLINNING, March 20
- vs Takumi Iroha, SEAdLINNNG, May 29
- vs Arisa Nakajima, “Hair vs Hair”, SEAdLINNNG, November 2
#22
Momo Watanabe
Previous Ranking: 2021 (6th) & 2022 (16th)
Years Unranked: 2015
Matches: 89
Places Worked: Stardom & Tokyo Gurentai
Titles Held: Wonder of Stardom Championship & Goddesses of Stardom Championship w/ Utami Hayashishita
Tournament: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ AZM & Konami, Stardom Cinderella Tournament, Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix, & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ AZM
The young Watanabe had a great year, winning a variety of championships in Stardom. She was already a bruiser striking this early into her career and really showed up in big match opportunities.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Tam Nakano, Stardom, January 14
- vs Jungle Kyona, Stardom, March 3
- vs Utami Hayashishita, Stardom, April 5
- w/ Utami Hayashishita vs Jungle Kyona & Konami, Stardom, July 15
#21
Daniel Makabe
Years Unranked: 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 65
Places Worked: 3-2-1 BATTLE!, WAC, wXw, ECCW, DOA, PPW, SCI, Riptide, BLP, Beyond, Breed Pro, 5CC, OWE, PWA, GCW, ISW, Pizza Party Pro, & Freelance
Tournaments: Scenic City Invitational (winner), wXw AMBITION 11, 3-2-1 BATTLE! Seattle Underground Title Tournament, Riptide Tag Team Tournament w/ Chris Brookes, wXw AMBITION Wildcard Edition (finals), PPW Title Tournament (finals), & 3-2-1 BATTLE! GO! Tournament (winner)
I’ve seen Makabe called the Budy Rose of the Pacific Northwest, and this is a really fun comparison. While mostly focused on matwork and submissions, his ability to story tell really sets him apart. A tremendous heel.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Jonathan Gresham, 3-2-1 BATTLE!, April 19
- vs Timothy Thatcher, 3-2-1 BATTLE!, July 12
- plus more
#20
Konami
Years Unranked: 2015 & 2021
Matches: 93
Place Worked: Stardom
Titles Held: Artist of Stardom Championship w/ Hana Kimura & Jungle Kyona & Goddesses of Stardom Championship w/ Jungle Kyona
Tournaments: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ AZM & Momo Watanabe, Stardom Cinderella Tournament (finals), Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix (finals), & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ Jungle Kyona
I always enjoy Konami, but I didn’t think about ranking until now. She had a tremendous year as one of the big shots in TCS. She had plenty of bigger opportunities and delivered in those situations, including main event title matches. She reminds me of Tajiri, and seeing Tajiri in Stardom is great fun.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Mayu Iwatani, Stardom, February 24
- vs Kagetsu, Stardom, May 26
- w/ Jungle Kyona vs Momo Watanabe & Utami Hayashishita, Stardom, July 15
- w/ Jungle Kyona vs Arisa Hoshiki & Tam Nakano, Stardom, November 24
- vs Arisa Hoshiki, Stardom, December 24
#19
Asuka
Previous Ranking: 2010 (3rd) & 2015 (10th)
Years Unranked: 2004, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 120
Place Worked: WWE
Titles Held: WWE SmackDown Women’s Championship & WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship w/ Kairi Sane
Being a non-World Champion in WWE as a woman makes it hard to put together a case, but I think Asuka accomplished it. From the tremendous title match with Lynch at the Rumble to the amazing team with Sane, she was a great performer all year. I can’t reiterate enough how awesome Kabuki Warriors were, and her having another awesome heel run really was much needed.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Becky Lynch, WWE, January 27
- w/ Kairi Sane vs Dakota Kai & Tegan Nox, NXT, October 30
- w/ Kairi Sane vs Becky Lynch & Charlotte Flair, “TLC”, WWE, December 15
#18
Chihiro Hashimoto
Years Unranked: 2021 & 2022
Matches: 97
Places Worked: Sendai Girls, DDT, Diana, WAVE, Marvelous, FCP, PURE-J, ZERO1, Dragon Gate, & Oz Academy
Titles Held: Sendai Girls Tag Team Championship w/ Mika Iwata, Sendai Girls World Championship (twice), & DDT KO-D Six Man Tag Team Championship w/ DASH Chisako & Meiko Satomura
Tournaments: Sendai Girls Royal Tag Team Tournament w/ Yuu (finals) & DDT D-Ou Grand Prix
I’m starting to think that any year Hashimoto has enough footage for me to watch, she’ll make the list somewhere. She is such a bruising brute of a wrestler who has a tremendous aura. Her taking on all challenges in Sendai Girls is perfect wrestling.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Kyoko Inoue, Diana, February 24
- vs Jordynne Grace, Sendai Girls, April 16
- vs Sareee, Sendai Girls, June 8
#17
WALTER
Previous Ranking: 2022 (2nd)
Years Unranked: 2010, 2015, & 2021
Matches: 67
Places Worked: WWE, wXw, PROGRESS, OTT, EVOLVE, FCP, Smash, BJW, & FWF
Titles Held: OTT World Championship, PROGRESS Atlas Championship, wXw World Tag Team Championship w/ Ilja Dragunov, PROGRESS Unified World Championship, & WWE NXT United Kingdom Championship
Tournaments: wXw 16 Carat Gold Tournament (finals) & wXw AMBITION 11 (winner)
A mixed bag from WALTER, from his usual hot start in wXw and the shocking match he dragged out of Müller to settling into NXT UK and having to have a rare show to have a great match.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Veit Müller, wXw, February 15
- vs Pete Dunne, NXT, April 5
- vs Pete Dunne, NXT UK, April 19
- plus more
#16
Io Shirai
Previous Ranking: 2015 (7th)
Years Unranked: 2010, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 69
Places Worked: WWE
Tournament: WWE Royal Rumble
Having a great run as a face and a heel in a single year is a great way to get ranked. She was still as great as she was in Stardom, just with fewer and different opportunities. Her heel turn and matches in that character were great.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Bianca Belair vs Kairi Sane vs Shayna Baszler, NXT, April 5
- vs Shayna Baszler, NXT, June 1
- vs Shayna Baszler, “Cage”, NXT, June 12
- vs Candice LeRae, NXT, August 10
#15
LA Park
aka La Parka
Previous Ranking: 2001 (4th), 2004 (9th), 2010 (5th), & 2015 (18th)
Years Unranked: 1993, 1994, 1997, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 76
Places Worked: AAA, MLW, G21, KAOZ, NLL, Invasion Indy, The Crash, Producciones Sanchez, Lucha Libre Boom, CMLL, PWM, AULL, IWRG, FMLL, Promociones Tao, WrestleRex, LEGEND, DEFY, Martinez Entertainment, Lucha Time, CWFH, LLE, Impact, GCW, TWE, WWW, & Warrior Wrestling
Titles Held: DDT Iron Man Heavy Metal Championship, XWW Universal Championship, G21 Heavyweight Championship, & G21 Tag Team Championship w/ El Hijo de LA Park
Park is an all-time great brawler, and even though he was slowly down, he was still great in 2019. He brings that aura of unpredictability and danger that few can bring.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Masato Tanaka, GCW
- vs Jacob Fatu, “No DQ”, MLW, November 2
- vs Blue Demon, Jr., IWRG, December 15
#14
Takumi Iroha
Years Unranked: 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 87
Places Worked: Marvelous, WAVE, SEAdLINNNG, Diana, & DDT
Titles Held: SEAdLINNNG Beyond The Sea Championship & Regina Di WAVE Championship
Tournament: Catch The WAVE (winner)
I’m so glad I finally got to rank Iroha, as lack of footage or injuries held her back before. The ace of Marvelous got to travel to SEAdLINNING and show them she’s one of the best Joshi workers of this century. With tremendous offence, kicks, and charisma, she is a true protege of Chigusa Nagayo.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Nanae Takahashi, SEAdLINNNG, May 29
- vs Arisa Nakajima, SEAdLINNNG, Semptember 18
- vs Mio Momono, Marvelous, November 3
- w/ Kaho Kobayashi vs Hazuki & Kagetsu, Sumire Natsu Produce Forever, December 15
#13
Daniel Bryan
Previous Ranking: 2004 (18th), 2010 (12th), & 2021 (18th)
Years Unranked: 2001, 2015, & 2022
Matches: 90
Place Worked: WWE
Titles Held: WWE Championship & WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championship w/ Rowan
The WrestleMania match with Kofi Kingston is a truly great performance which would cement Bryan onto the list. However, adding on his heel work throughout the year, he’s in the top 15.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Kevin Owens vs Mustafi Ali, WWE, March 10
- vs Kofi Kingston, WWE, April 7 (#3 MOTY)
- w/ Roman Reigns vs Erick Rowan & Luke Harper, WWE, October 6
#12
Orange Cassidy
aka Fire Ant
Years Unranked: 2004, 2010, 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 102
Places Worked: GCW, Beyond, CHIKARA, NYWC, Outlaw Wrestling, PWG, AEW, BLP, LVAC, Bar Wrestling, F1RST, ICW, EVOLVE, Flying V, IWTV, A1, HOH, FCP, PWA Black Label, WrestlePro, Smash, WC, SFP, Wild Zero, MCW, OTT, Prestige, Ground Zero, B!P, BTW, Destiny, TRUE, & SLA
Titles Held: IWTV Independent Wrestling Championship (twice), F1RST Wrestling Uptown VFW Championship, & A1 Zero Gravity Championship
Tournaments: NYWC/Outlaw Wrestling King & Queen Tournament w/ Kris Statlander (finals), PWG Battle of Los Angeles, BLP Turbo Graps 16, CHIKARA King of Trios as Fire Ant w/ Green Ant & Thief Ant, PWA Black Label Colosseum Tournament, FCP Infinity Tournament, & AEW Dynamite Diamond Ring
Watching Cassidy transform from a comedy worker to the ace of the northeast indies was a great ride, and if you like his current title run in AEW, you’ll like this as well. He was not only hilarious but also found tremendous ways to bring his character into serious great matches.
Recommended Matches:
- w/ Session Moth Martina vs Brian Cage & Jordynne Grace, Beyond, April 3
- vs Jonathan Gresham, “European Rounds”, IWTV, April 4
- vs Joey Janella, GCW, May 4
- vs Kris Statlander, IWTV, May 26
- w/ Chuck Taylor vs BLANK & Still Life, Beyond, June 19
#11
Sareee
Years Unranked: 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 85
Places Worked: Sendai Girls, Diana, Marvelous, WAVE, Dotonbori Pro, MBPW, JTO, Ice Ribbon, HEAT UP, ZERO1, & GPS
Titles Held: Sendai Girls World Championship & World Woman Pro-Wrestling Diana World Championship
Tournament: Sendai Girls Royal Rag Tournament w/ Nanami
Sareee went from a young up-and-comer to the ace of Sendai Girls in 2019, and it was a great story. Her facing all these legends and not only keeping up with them but surpassing them was impressive.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Meiko Satomura, Sendai Girls, April 16
- vs Chihiro Hashimoto, Sendai Girls, June 8
- vs Giulia, Minoru Tanaka Produce, June 18
- vs DASH Chisako, Sendai Girls, July 7
- vs Tsukasa Fujimoto, Ice Ribbon, September 14
#10
Tam Nakano
Previous Ranking: 2021 (4th) & 2022 (7th)
Years Unranked: none
Matches: 84
Places Worked: Stardom & Tokyo Gurentai
Titles Held: Artist of Stardom Championship w/ Mayu Iwatani & Saki Kashima (twice)
Tournaments: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ Arisa Hoshiki & Saki Kashima (finals), Stardom Cinderella Tournament, Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix, & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ Arisa Hoshiki (winner)
Tam, the queen storyteller in wrestling today, spent most of the year with the Hoshiki story. As amazing as that was, it would be dead without Nakano. I may be biased due to her being one of my favourites, but I don’t think anyone can deny she was a great character in 2019 with some great matches.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Momo Watanabe, Stardom, January 14
- vs Kagetsu, Stardom, April 29
- vs Arisa Hoshiki, Stardom, June 16 (#2 MOTY)
- vs Mayu Iwatani, Stardom, September 7
- w/ Arisa Hoshiki vs Jungle Kyona & Konami, Stardom, November 24
#9
Shayna Baszler
Years Unranked: 2021 & 2022
Matches: 80
Places Worked: WWE
Title Held: WWE NXT Women’s Championship
I had completely forgotten that there was a time when Baszler was treated properly in WWE. The badass dominant champion of NXT was a great run for her and put her in a fun contrast with the majority of the roster she faced. When it was finally time for her to lose and move on, she did so, making a new star.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Bianca Belair, NXT, January 26
- vs Bianca Belair vs Io Shirai vs Kairi Sane, NXT, April 5
- vs Io Shirai, NXT, June 1
- vs Io Shirai, “Cage”, NXT, June 12
- vs Rhea Ripley, NXT, December 18
#8
Jungle Kyona
Years Unranked: 2022
Matches: 86
Places Worked: Stardom, YMZ, & Tokyo Gurentai
Titles Held: Artist of Stardom Championship w/ Hana Kimura & Konami & Goddesses of Stardom Championship w/ Konami
Tournaments: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ Natsuko Tora & Ruaka, Stardom Cinderella Tournament, Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix, & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ Konami
Jungle in TCS is my favourite version of Jungle. Her getting so close but just coming up short led to dramatic storytelling. This might be the best year of her career.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Momo Watanabe, Stardom, March 3
- w/ Konami vs Momo Watanabe & Utami Hayashishita, Stardom, July 15
- vs Arisa Hoshiki, Stardom, August 10 (#7 MOTY)
- w/ Konami vs Arisa Hoshiki & Tam Nakano, Stardom, November 24
#7
El Barbaro Cavernario
Years Unranked: 2015, 2021, & 2022
Matches: 125
Places Worked: CMLL, NJPW, ROH, The Crash, AULL, RevPro, Martinez Entertainment,
Lucha Libre Real, & Promociones Bello
Title Held: Mexican National Light Heavyweight Champion
Tournaments: Campeon Universal del CMLL, CMLL Torneo National de Parejas Incredibles w/ Titan (winner), CMLL Torneo Incredible de Parejas w/ Flyer, CMLL Torneo Gran Alternativa w/ Espanto, Jr., & RevPro British J Cup
Every single spotlight match he had, he delivered, and he was a lot of fun in the random pointless trios matches as well. They are such a ridiculous bumper with great charisma and real smarts for putting together an exciting match.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Dragon Lee, CMLL, January 4
- vs Titan, CMLL, February 22
- vs Mistico, CMLL, May 24
#6
“The Boss” Sasha Banks
Previous Ranking: 2015 (1st) & 2021 (12th)
Years Unranked: 2022
Matches: 73
Place Worked: WWE
Title Held: WWE Women’s Tag Team Champion w/ Bayley
Banks spent the first half of the year trying to establish a women’s tag division and then moved into a great feud with Becky Lynch. She was great doing both of those things. The Boss, even limited, is one of the greatest in the world.
Recommended Matches:
- Elimination Chamber Tag Match, WWE, February 17
- w/ Bayley vs Becky Lynch & Charlotte Flair, WWE, September 9
- vs Becky Lynch, WWE, September 15
- vs Becky Lynch, “Hell in a Cell”, WWE, October 6 (#9 MOTY)
- plus more
#5
Mayu Iwatani
Previous Ranking: 2015 (12th), 2021 (10th), & 2022 (5th)
Years Unranked: none
Matches: 78
Places Worked: Stardom, ROH, EVE, Diana, & NJPW
Titles Held: ROH Women of Honor World Championship, Artist of Stardom Championship w/ Saki Kashima & Tam Nakano (twice), & World of Stardom Championship
Tournaments: Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League
Mayu continued to be the GOAT of Stardom and had another great year with the Red Belt and, weirdly, the ROH Title. The ROH trips didn’t yield much, but at least she had some great defences of that belt in Stardom.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Kelly Klein, ROH, February 10
- vs Konami, Stardom, February 24
- vs Tam Nakano, Stardom, September 7
- w/ Arisa Hoshiki vs Hazuki & Kagetsu, Stardom, December 1
- vs Kagetsu, Stardom, December 24
- plus more
#4
Kagetsu
Previous Ranking: 2015 (24th)
Years Unranked: 2010
Matches: 97
Places Worked: Stardom, EVE, ROH, & Tokyo Gurentai
Titles Held: World of Stardom Championship & Artist of Stardom Championship w/ Andras Miyagi & Natsu Sumire
Tournaments: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ Hazuki & Natsu Sumire, Stardom Cinderella Tournament, Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix, & Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ Natsu Sumire
The main heel in Stardom, Kagetsu spent a lof the year as the Red Belt Champion and all of the year kicking ass. He cut a unique presence as he could go with the more dramatic work-rate action, but he mostly enjoyed being a badass. I loved him against lesser opponents being arrogant and just plain mean, but giving them enough to come out looking great.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Tam Nakano, Stardom, April 29
- vs Konami, Stardom, May 26
- w/ Hazuki vs Arisa Hoshiki & Mayu Iwatani, Stardom, December 1
- w/ Hazuki vs Kaho Kobayashi & Takumi Iroha, Sumire Natsu Produce Forever, December 15
- vs Mayu Iwatani, Stardom, December 24
#3
“The Man” Becky Lynch
Previous Ranking: 2015 (16th)
Years Unranked: 2021 & 2022
Matches: 131
Place Worked: WWE
Titles Held: WWE SmackDown Women’s Championship & WWE Raw Women’s Championship
Tournament: WWE Royal Rumble (winner)
Becky Lynch really took off in 2019, winning the first WrestleMania main evented by women. Her year stretched far beyond great promos, and being super over, she also had tremendous matches, including the great feud with Sasha Banks. She was must watch every time she was on screen.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Asuka, WWE, January 27
- w/ Charlotte Flair vs Bayley & Sasha Banks, WWE, September 9
- vs Sasha Banks, WWE, September 15
- vs Sasha Banks, “Hell in a Cell”, WWE, October 6 (#9 MOTY)
- w/ Charlotte Flair vs Asuka & Kairi Sane, “TLC”, WWE, December 15
- plus more
#2
Arisa Hoshiki
Years Unranked: none
Matches: 84
Places Worked: Stardom & EVE
Title Held: Wonder of Stardom Championship
Tournaments: Stardom Trios Tag Team Tournament w/ Saki Kashima & Tam Nakano (finals), Stardom Cinderella Tournament (winner), Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix, Stardom Goddesses of Stardom Tag League w/ Tam Nakano (winner)
What a wild career Hoshiki had. 2019 was the only year she worked over 15 matches; she debuted in 2018 and retired in 2020, and ended up #2 on this list. Her ability to get kicks off at unique angles and time them perfectly makes her stand out. She had such a great ability to step up in big matches and was instantly likable as a babyface. What a tremendous year as the Wonder of Stardom Champion, working the long-term story with Tam Nakano and Jungle Kyona.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Tam Nakano, Stardom, June 16 (#2 MOTY)
- vs Hazuki, Stardom, July 24
- vs Jungle Kyona, Stardom, August 10 (#7 MOTY)
- w/ Tam Nakano vs Jungle Kyona & Konami, Stardom, November 24
- vs Konami, Stardom, December 24
- plus more
#1
“The Latina Sensation”
Mercedes Martinez
Previous Ranking: 2010 (19th) & 2021 (17th)
Years Unranked: 2004 & 2022
Matches: 65
Places Worked: EVE, SHIMMER, Rise, Shine, NHPW, PPW, AWS, Beyond, AEW, Femmes Fatles, RevPro, AIW, VIP, Ladies Night Out, Hurricane Pro, WAW, UCE, Riptide, UPWA, F1RST, WOW, & APW
Titles Held: Phoenix of RISE Championship, IndyGurlz Australia Championship, PPW Women’s Championship, SHIMMER Tag Team Championship w/ Cheerleader Melissa, AWS Heavyweight Championship, SHINE Championship, Bellatrix World Championship, & Femmes Fatales Championship
Tournaments: NHPW Global Conflict X Tournament (finals), EVE Tag Team Title Tournament w/ Laura Di Matteo (finals), & EVE SHE-1
In 2019 Martinez worked everywhere, having great matches with great wrestlers and wrestlers she had to completely carry. It was similar to Chris Hero’s 2010, a year that also got him to #1 on my list. During that year, she had me ordering all kinds of shows and searching her out. Everything was entertaining to great, and I had 11 or so matches of her’s on my spreadsheet. Bonus, I met her in Toronto at The Summit, and she was the nicest person alive.
Recommended Matches:
- vs Kay Lee Ray, EVE, February 9
- vs Kylie Rae, “No Ropes Submission”, RISE, March 29 (#1 MOTY)
- vs Charlie Morgan, SHIMMER, March 30
- vs Thunder Rosa, Hurricane Pro, July 27
- vs Jordynne Grace, The Summit, August 10 (#10 MOTY)
- plus more
There we have it; after months of watching the footage, I can move on from 2019. Did you love this list, or did you love it? Contact me on Twitter or Discord to let me know.
Upcoming!
As a complete change of pace, let’s explore 1989 next!
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group, and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
Trans Rights!
It’s a horrible time to be trans right now, so please donate to the lovely folks here who save lives!
The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Week: WrestleMania Edition (2023-04-07)
It’s WrestleMania weekend, but I didn’t watch as much as in the past. I am not into the Indies as much as I was in 2019. Plus this week is ending early, as I am travelling this weekend.
#9
Brock Lesnar vs Omos
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Sunday
April 2, 2023
Brock sold extremely well and Omos looked great throwing Brock around the ring. I probably would had liked this a lot more if Brock didn’t seemingly overcome Omos so easily in the end.
Rating: 7/10
#8
Ai Houzan vs Unagi Sayaka
Marvelous
March 26, 2023
Houzan came to fight, but Unagi was having none of her. Ungai’s stomp kicks seemed even more vicious in this one. I guess her size came into play. I thought underdog Unagi was the best, but maybe pissed-off overdog Unagi is better?
Rating: 7/10
#7
Emi Sakura vs Hikaru Shida
Gatoh Move Gtmv #3 ~ Cute Cheat Day
September 10, 2019
A really fun match where Shida was the badass heel here beating down Sakura for most of the match and mocking her. Emi gets some good hope spots until it gets a very exciting finishing stretch.
Rating: 7/10
#6
Athena vs Yuka Sakazaki
“ROH Women’s World Championship”
ROH Supercard of Honor
March 31, 2023
I’ve always been a fan of Athena and it’s very nice to see her getting a bigger push. Too bad the crowd sucked, because this was a fun match. Athena was a steamroller and Sakazaki did a good job of trying to overcome that, but ultimately falling short.
Rating: 7/10
#5
Becky Lynch, Lita, & Trish Stratus vs Bayley, Dakota Kai, & IYO SKY
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Saturday
April 1, 2023
This match is filled with some of my favourite wrestlers ever, so it’s just nice to see. It starts slow with an okay face in peril segment with Lita, but once Trish comes in for the hot tag this match rules! It kind of breaks down and is filled with a lot of excitement and some great dives, including Io Shira’s moonsault! It all comes down tho the two main current stars as it should be for a definitive finish!
Rating: 7/10
#4
Charlotte Flair vs Rhea Ripley
“WWE SmackDown Women’s Championship”
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Saturday
April 1, 2023
A match that built from a slow start to upping itself all along the way until it had a great finish. It was so very physical and intense, even drawing blood. Charlotte not being able to put Rhea away was a tremendous moment, as was Rhea ending it!
Rating: 8.5/10
#3
The Usos vs Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn
“WWE Raw & SmackDown Tag Team Championship”
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Saturday
April 1, 2023
Although this match should had been the perfect end to Roman Reigns’ title reign, at least it was the perfect end to the reign of the Usos.
One of the best face in peril segments ever in WWE history on Uso, let to a great hot tag for Owens. We got a bueatufl teams stare down, and then the very satisfying Sami Zayn victory. A rare perfect ending for the WWE.
Rating: 8.75/10
#2
Bianca Belair vs Asuka
“WWE Raw Women’s Championship”
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Sunday
April 2, 2023
Belair’s etrance was one of, if not the best, in WWE history. She may be the best big match wrestler in the WWE and her WrestleMania career is kind of unreal and she added to that here.
Belair has some of the greatest power moves ever, it’s really unreal. Asuka was so awesome in her evil way, always trying to count everything with a submission, but the power was hard to contend with. The whole apron segment was amazing, but nothing tops the finish. Bianca just powering out of the armbar into the KOD was a great WrestleMania moment!
Rating: 8.75/10
“Match of the Week”
Gunther vs Drew McIntyre vs Sheamus
“WWE Intercontinental Championship Triple Threat”
WWE WrestleMania 39 – Sunday
April 2, 2023
This was a straight forward stiff war. By the end, everyone had red chests and Sheamus’ was bleeding. Usually the “drama” of the Triple Threat matches bug me, but here taking a breather after all those beatings made sense. Gunther continues to look like the most unbeatable badass in the WWE.
Rating: 8.75/10
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
Trans Rights!
It’s a horrible time to be trans right now, so please donate to the lovely folks here, who save lives!
The Best Matches I’ve Watched This Week (2023-03-31)
Now that 2001 is out of the way I was able to spend this week getting caught up on current wrestling and spending some time focussing on my next year of doing top 25s, 2019.
#12
Wasteland War Party vs 121000000
“Princess Tag Team Championship”
TJPW Grand Princess
March 18, 2023
An entertaining tag match with an amazing cast of characters! Max always tugs at my enby heart, but Maki Itoh was the star here. The War Party was dominant early and it told a great story of the TJPW super team overcoming the pure power of the War Party.
Rating: 7/10
#11
Aja Kong vs Yuki Arai
TJPW Grand Princess
March 18, 2023
This was a blast and hits my favourite type of match, young underdog vs dominant veteran. Arai used axe kicks to try to counteract Kong’s power and it worked, mostly. It was dramatic and another great Kong performance!
Rating: 7/10
#10
KARMA & Starlight Kid vs. MIRAI & Tomoka Inaba
“New Blood Tag Team Title Tournament Finals”
Stardom New Blood Premium
March 25, 2023
This was an excellent tag match that built up the drama and excitement as it reached its climax. SLK was on fire and seemed to be the focus of the match and she brought a lot of the High Speed elements into this match. Exactly what you want from the finals of a tournament.
Rating: 7.25/10
#9
Giulia vs Himeka
“Himeka Retirement Road”
Stardom
March 16, 2023
An emotional stop on the Himeka retirement tour as she faces her stablemate Giulia. It was a strike-heavy match and both were putting in maximum effort for a smaller show. An emotional post-match put this over the top for me.
Rating: 7.5/10
#8
Aja Kong & Kyoko Inoue vs Blizzard Yuki & Manami Toyota
Bridge of Dreams ~ Dome Spring Full Bloom
April 2, 1995
AJW represents at the Tokyo Dome with an excellent showcase match. Each had awesome moments and Kong looked especially brutal with her slams. Toyota and Kong work hard to make up for their disappointing title change a few weeks before this match.
Rating: 7.75/10
#7
Miu Watanabe vs Rika Tatsumi
“TJPW International Princess Championship”
TJPW Grand Princess
March 18, 2023
This match had a lot of elements I loved, but some I rather disliked. Watanabe has some of my favourite offences and I love the way she sells, I think she did a great job carrying this one. Tatsumi I had issues with it, I am not sure if it was the character or the too much comedy of the style, but it was rather distracting. The story of working on Watanabe’s legs to prevent her big offence later made sense. How can you not enjoy a match with a Spinning Dragon Sleeper?
Rating: 7.75/10
#6
Asuka vs Becky Lynch
“WWE SmackDown Women’s Championship”
WWE Royal Rumble
January 29, 2019
I am not sure how I missed putting this match in 2019, but it’s pretty darn good. The crowd is really hot as two top stars are very even trying to put the other away. They had tremendous transitions and both were really going for the submissions. The vicious bump off the apron elevates this, along with the great finishing sequence.
Rating: 8/10
#5
Miyu Amasaki vs Nanae Takahashi
“Passion Injection Match”
Stardom Miyu Amasaki Triumphal Return
March 19, 2023
The one-year anniversary of Miyu Amasaki’s debut and she is facing the legendary Takahashi in her hometown in the gorgeous KBS Hall and it’s a great match. Takahashi beats the passion into Amasaki it looks like it could be a legendary feud brewing. Amasaki has great leg submissions and focuses on offence, she’s rather smooth for someone so young in her career and Takahashi is great as the veteran bully. Great hope spots and a great match.
Post-match, Takahashi says the referee is on the take but she overcame. They set up future matches and I am very excited about that.
Rating: 8/10
#4
Chihiro Hashimto vs Mio Momono
Marvelous
March 15, 2023
A classic power vs speed match-up that started slowly, but built up to get more and more exciting until a great finishing sequence. Momono is such a cool wrestler watching her try to evade as much of Hashimoto’s power offence as possible.
Rating: 8.25/10
#3
Bayley & Sasha Banks vs Becky Lynch & Charlotte Flair
WWE Raw
September 9, 2019
The Four Horsewomen collide live in MSG in a tremendous tag team match! They felt like they were on a mission to upstage everyone and the crowd was really hot for it. My favourite moment was when Charlotte had the Figure-8 on Sasha and Bayley broke that up by rolling Becky Lynch up into it! Classic tag wrestling here!
Rating: 8.25/10
#2
KAIRI & Nanae Takahashi vs Tam Nakano & Waka Tsukiyama
Stardom New Blood Premium
March 25, 2023
After years of never getting a win in Stardom, Waka Tsukiyama has one last chance to win or she will be kicked out of Comsic Angels and she’s facing two legends. It’s a perfect story and it had a perfect ending.
Waka had her serious face on, and was overpowered, but fought and fought before she rolled up the legend in the end. The KAIRI and Tam parts ruled as well. It was very dramatic with the story throughout. The post-match was perfect too.
This is pro-wrestling!
Rating: 8.25/10
“Fan Favourite”
The Giant vs Lex Luger
WCW Starrcade
December 29, 1996
This one comes from Elliott on the discord and, weirdly, I don’t think I’ve ever seen Starrcade 1996.
You could tell this was going to be a great one from the very hot crowd and with the amazing lock-up start to the match. It played the classic formula of seeing if the powerful man is strong enough to overcome the giant man. The Giant did a great job being the giant man early on and the hope spots by Luger were awesome. We get to a referee bump and Luger has it, but then nWo shenanigans. Thankfully it all ends with much better Sting shenanigans and an excellent finish.
Rating: 7.25/10
“Match of the Week”
Chigusa Nagayo & Dynamite Kansai vs Devil Masami & Mayumi Ozaki
GAEA Memorial First Gong In Korakuen
April 15, 1995
This is the main event of the very first GAEA show and it’s the perfect way to establish a promotion!
I find it really interesting that Kansai and Nagayo are dressed normally, but Masami is dressed as Super Heel Masami and Ozaki is dressed for a street fight. Ozaki knew what was up because this was one of the most violent wild bloody brawls I have ever seen.
It was so out of control the ring crew started taking apart the ring mid-match and the wrenches they used became a weapon for Ozaki. The sight of a half-destroyed ring with brawling everywhere is a great sight!
The match keeps escalating and many times you think it is over, but it instead, just gets more violent! All of this leads up to an all-time great finish, where Nagayo goes for the Running Three on Ozaki, but Masami on the outside just stabs Nagayo with a sword, allowing Ozaki to counter into a rollup.
This is an all-time classic that will be on my greatest match-ever list!
Rating: 9.5/10
Thoughts
What did you think of these matches? What matches do you want to recommend me to watch? Preferably hit me up with those 2019 suggestions. You can do that with the info below!
You can discuss this on Twitter!
Discord
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project and anything else under the sun. It’s an open and welcoming group and I am very proud of it. Everyone is welcome:
Join:
We also do weekly watch-along parties with chat!
Trans Rights!
It’s a horrible time to be trans right now, so please donate to the lovely folks here, who save lives!
2022 Match of the Year
2022 was an excellent year for high-end matches and a significant return for WWE on my list. Stardom, of course, reigned supreme for me. They are my go-to promotion. It was challenging to narrow this list down, so there are quite a lot of honourable mentions. I rated 178 matches in 2022 as 7/10 or higher.
Honourable Mentions
- AZM vs Starlight Kid, Stardom, February 23
- Giulia vs Syuri, Stardom, March 26
- Mayu Iwatani vs Syuri, Stardom, March 27
- Arisa Nakajima vs Tsukasa Fujimoto, SEAdLINNNG, April 29
- Mayu Iwatani vs Starlight Kid, Stardom, October 1
- Jordynne Grace vs Masha Slamovich, Impact, October 7
- Mayu Iwatani vs Utami Hayashishita, Stardom, October 23
- Syuri vs Utami Hayashishita, Stardom, November 19
#10
Pentagon, Jr. vs Villano IV
“Ruleta De La Muerte Final Mask Vs. Mask Match”
AAA TripleMania XXX: Mexico City
October 15
Arena Ciudad de Mexico
I always love a big mask vs mask match. They always have drama and emotions that are hard to reach otherwise. This one was not like the CMLL ones, as it was a bloody and violent affair. Villano IV was a great underdog. A true throwback to violent mask matches of the past.
#9
Deonna Purrazzo vs Mickie James
“Impact Knockouts Championship Texas Death Match”
Impact Hard to Kill
January 8
The Factory in Deep Ellum
A violent and bloody “Texas Death Match” is a must-watch. Similar to my #10 match, this is a blast from the past with a modern twist. A great feud ending hate brawl.
#8
The Bloodline (Jey & Jimmy Uso, Roman Reigns, Sami Zayn, & Solo Sikoa)
vs
Drew McIntyre, Kevin Owens, Butch, Ridge Holland, & Sheamus
“War Games”
WWE Survivor Series
November 26
TD Garden
I seem to be alone for the love of this match, but I love great storytelling and the story of Sami Zayn trying to prove his loyalty to The Bloodline in this one was top-notch. Add in his friendship with Kevin Owens and this one had levels. Everyone played their roles well and this was a great brawl too. It was big-time dramatic down the stretch too with such a satisfying conclusion.
#7
Gunther vs Sheamus
“WWE Intercontinental Championship”
WWE Clash at the Castle
September 3
Principality Stadium
These two beat the hell out of each other in their home continent which was really hot. This battle brought the IC Title back to where it should be, the worker’s title held by a future star. Sheamus doesn’t get enough credit for being a great babyface who can draw great sympathy. Let’s not beat around the bush here, this was a stiff war!
#6
The Usos vs The Street Profits
“WWE Raw & SmackDown Tag Team Championship”
WWE Money in the Bank
July 2
MGM Grand Garden Arena
I didn’t see this match get too much hype, but it was the best tag team match of the year. The Street Profits were perfect underdog babyfaces against the Usos who refused to stay down. All of their comebacks were magical and this was a perfect mix of old-school tag team wrestling with modern excitement style.
#5
Giulia vs Tam Nakano
“5STAR Grand Prix 2022 Final Match”
Stardom 5STAR Grand Prix 2022: Championship Battle
October 1
Musashino Forest Sports Plaza Main Arena
The two long-term rivals reach the finals of the 5Star Grand Prix and have to do it one more time. Giulia and Tam added to their all-time great feud with another classic. Both play their roles perfectly with the high stakes of the tournament on the line.
#4
KAIRI vs Mayu Iwatani
“IWGP Women’s Title Tournament Final”
NJPW/Stardom Historic X-over
November 20
Ariake Arena
A historic match that main evented the first-ever NJPW/Stardom show for the first-ever IWGP Women’s Championship. These two know how to feel special and make matches feel big time and they delivered on that front. Great emotions and great storytelling in this one.
#3
Giulia vs Mayu Iwatani
“Rights to Challenge for the World of Stardom Title”
Stardom Nagoya Supreme Fight
January 29
Aichi Prefectural Gymnasium
This was the match to determine who would get the World of Stardom Title shot at Stardom’s biggest show ever and they fought like that. It had a very old-school approach, but incorporated modern Japanese wrestling in a fresh way. A thirty-minute draw that felt like a twenty-minute match, and didn’t let on that it was a draw.
#2
Becky Lynch vs Bianca Belair
“WWE Raw Women’s Championship”
WWE WrestleMania 38: Saturday
April 2
AT&T Stadium
The main event of WrestleMania delivered big (Becks?) time! They called back to their SummerSlam match early and then continued with a brilliant heel performance by Lynch. The psychology was great and this was an instant classic.
#1
Giulia
vs
Syuri
“World of Stardom Championship”
December 29
Ryōgoku Kokugikan
I waited on putting out this list until this match had ended and that was a wise decision as it is my match of the year. A very long-term storyline that paid off in a highly emotional moment on a grand stage, this is pro-wrestling!
I loved that this was a different kind of epic. At no point did they try to pad the time with pointless limp work that went nowhere. Nope, these two went to war from the opening bell to the end. So many huge moments and spots including an Exploder suplex from the ramp to the audience!
They had the finishing sequence was perfect. They were struggling for everything. One could say it had “botches” or they were “sloppy”, but it really felt like they were destroyed. Great match, on the same level as the Dream Queendom match between Utami and Syuri last December.
Socials
If you want to discuss this you can do it on Twitter:
We also have a lovely discord community to discuss the greatest wrestler ever project. Also every Thursday/Sunday we do watch parties. Join:
Help!
Donate to the lovely folks here, who save lives.
Coming Soon!
My top 25 wrestlers of 2022.
Recent Comments